I think we all love Gaga enough that we can throw both out. No one is being offensive, just stating opinions around the field.
Anyway, I have a feeling I'm going to really dislike this movie, lol, but I can't wait to see it and hope Gaga herself takes my breath away.
It's been clear since they skipped all the festivals and have been pretty mum until now they aren't going for Oscars (except maybe some acting/scenic ones).