Charts Discussion Thread (911 / Voting Era)

[Fame Romance]

Beyond the overall delusion and extreme inflation, the real kii is someone thinking Video Mess sold 2.2M units 

[Andreu]

5 minutes ago, Malazam said:

1) Fill the blank with a single from Lady GaGa that didn't top the Hot 100.

-----------

 

Til it Happens to you

[Dean Judaster]

1 minute ago, Swallow said:

in February Gaga will become the first old MPG to have four solo 500m songs on Spotify so we can use that 

the way it will erase the narrative Gaga needs collabs whew

[Miaou]

2 minutes ago, Fame Romance said:

Beyond the overall delusion and extreme inflation, the real kii is someone thinking Video Mess sold 2.2M units 

and Miss Clownleta believes him 

[artgagapop]

8 minutes ago, Miaou said:

Paparazzi could have been #1 if her team didn't mess up 

Paparazzi had it's peak in Sweden during the Alejandro era with both Alejandro and Telephone in the top 10, she was so massive back then but her team was still was just as messy when it comes to singles as they are now 

[OreoÀDeux Pronounshe/him]

1 hour ago, beng said:

Perfect Illusion was a warning sign huh

Perfect Illusion's vocals should have been a lot more subdueb in my opinion

[OreoÀDeux Pronounshe/him]

56 minutes ago, Nemanja said:

his production on chromatica is fu**ing fantastic, soo i dont know what you talking about

Maybe its just a matter of taste. I tend to prefer more crowded and dynamic productions a la btw or artpop, whereas chromatica for me sounds a little too repetitive and predictive. I love little details and unexpected twists in the production.

[Malazam]

3 minutes ago, Andreu said:

Til it Happens to you

War flashbacks of it topping the Club Charts

[Fame Romance]

https://pca.eonline.com/music/the-female-artist-of-2020
Don’t forget to vote for the PCAs

[little legend]

Wow i wasnt online for a couple hours and already all these pages

Did i miss anything? Is Chromatica still underperforming and Shallow still slaying? Any news from miss Alicia? Is her the new single?

[Dean Judaster]

1 minute ago, Fame Romance said:

https://pca.eonline.com/music/the-female-artist-of-2020
Don’t forget to vote for the PCAs

are you still using my technique and voting for my show lmao

Edited October 12, 2020 by DeanClownchester

[Fame Romance]

5 minutes ago, DeanClownchester said:

are you still using my technique and voting for my show lmao

Yeah I bulk vote when I have time and vote for Supernatural each time 

[artgagapop]

2 minutes ago, Delusional said:

I feel like Million Reasons should have been the Joanne lead with Perfect Illusion as the second single 

(MR with a different video ofc)

Should been 
A-YO
MR
JW(video only)
TC (added to streaming as a bonus track + MV)
Joanne with an actual single push for the grammys 

[Mylo]

Just now, Delusional said:

I feel like Million Reasons should have been the Joanne lead with Perfect Illusion as the second single 

(MR with a different video ofc)

I still believe they should have gone for A-Yo, because, despite it being pretty upbeat, it best represents the whole Joanne's "country-pop" vibe!

But at the end of the day I wouldn't change anything of that era, even Perfect Bomb slumping chart-run

[OreoÀDeux Pronounshe/him]

5 minutes ago, Delusional said:

I feel like Million Reasons should have been the Joanne lead with Perfect Illusion as the second single 

(MR with a different video ofc)

This. They were afraid to allienate the fanbase but that was always going to happen anyways so might as well push the good commercially viable and radio friendly song as a single instead of a song that's sort of reminescent of the gaga-brand but without a good hook and with overwhelming vocals. 

It would have been a different story for Joanne if they pushed MR first imo. It still turned out fine because of the SB but yeah

Edited October 12, 2020 by zcasx

[chartgaga]

A-Yo was the perfect intro to the Joanne era IMO, a mix of Shake It Off beat while still being country influenced and a bop!

I loved Perfect Illusion and appreciate it more than most of her leads but A-YO would have slapped with a great video

then Million Reasons around SuperBowl time, I'm sure if released then with the push it could have gone more than #4 and 20 weeks charting

then Dancin In Circles in the summer

[Mylo]

The way this country-pop, banging jam™ still goes off though, poor Diggin' My Grave

[chartgaga]

Just now, Mylo said:

The way this country-pop, banging jam™ still goes off though, poor Diggin' My Grave

I remember one of my best friend was a OGH and hated Perfect Illusion but really loved A-YO bc she found it good lyrically, she loved the production and her vocals on it, calling it mature yet still fun, pop but not dumb.

she now likes Gaga because of Five Foot Two, A Star is Born and her performance in front of the presidents

 

A-YO was the perfect intro, and she missed it

[artgagapop]

1 minute ago, Mylo said:

The way this country-pop, banging jam™ still goes off though, poor Diggin' My Grave

I think it actually had potential to be a decent sized hit, it was higher then MR after SNL, although A-Yo was a newer song but still. 

[0707alp]

Perfect Illusion is literally perfect as it is. An angry energy rush that hypes you up and wears you down at the same time. Wearing out part killed its single potential but she transferred her energy through that song like no other. Dont talk sh*t about that song.