Charts Discussion Thread (911 / Voting Era)

[DonnieDarko]

Enigma is a flawless song. 

[little legend]

Just now, Twitter said:

Unpopular opinion: that should have been a single.

I agree. Its the perfect song coming from ASIB era and it coukdnt do worse than Stupid Flop. It will be also acclaimed and the GP would have get chills when Gaga performed it live especially at the part *We could be lovers, even just tonight
We could be AANNYTTHINGGG you want*

Spoiler

Well Gaga would have never promoted but thats another story

 

[little legend]

1 minute ago, Twitter said:

I agree and mildly disagree. Stupid Love still remained a good lead single and is one of my favorites on Chromatica. It wasn’t a flop or bad single.

However, I do believe Enigma would’ve been a better lead single coming from the raw vocals of Shallow to Enigma. Would’ve been more powerful and GP successful than SL. 

Stupid Love is literally the worst lead single in human history but lets just focus on how good Enigma is 

[entela]

 

30 minutes ago, little legend said:

Stupid Love is literally the worst lead single in human history but lets just focus on how good Enigma is 

Me! still exists...

Anyway the best lead would have been Alice, great opener/soundwise represents the album better and with an amazing video were she could have played with the Alice lost/entering Chromatica concept.

 

[Fame Romance]

2 minutes ago, entela said:

 

Me! still exists...

Anyway the best lead would have been Alice, great opener/soundwise represents the album better and with an amazing video were she could have played with the Alice lost/entering Chromatica concept.

 

For once that you spilled

[Andreu]

 

Will come for 500 next week i fear

[TINDER PronounsHe/Him]

[little legend]

2 minutes ago, TINDER said:

I dont know if i should use the lol or the sad reaction

[Laurastreep]

300k likes...only to open with 40k.

This is why you should never trust twitter hyping you. It never translates to sales...otherwise Beyonce or Normani would be able to get a hit.

[Laurastreep]

It's on Power rotation now...objectively a weaker song than ROM (soundwise), yet it's getting PR treatment something ROM never got.

Scooter doing his thing with his client.

[Moonlight Shadow]

19 minutes ago, TINDER said:

Sad but true 

[little legend]

ROM sounds more radio and GP friendly and both Gaga and Ariana are singing it. I don't understand how it didnt reach at least 100m audience on there. Radios in US are really corrupted

[Fame Romance]

31 minutes ago, Laurastreep said:

It's on Power rotation now...objectively a weaker song than ROM (soundwise), yet it's getting PR treatment something ROM never got.

Scooter doing his thing with his client.

At least they're not that obvious with the payola here, ME! had the same airplay after one week that Positons has after a month 

That's why ME! didn't freefall on its second week, but the week after it went downhill because no one was streaming or buying and radio was stagnant untill the terrible callouts killed it

Edited November 29, 2020 by Fame Romance

[MissAsia]

28 minutes ago, little legend said:

ROM sounds more radio and GP friendly and both Gaga and Ariana are singing it. I don't understand how it didnt reach at least 100m audience on there. Radios in US are really corrupted

It had bad callouts score.. 

Maybe positions is doing better

[Fame Romance]

Middays:

Shallow: 1,329,081,292 (+1,051,823)

ROM: 451,416,439 (+1,002,214)

ARUTW: 518,998,012 (+483,563)

Bad Romance: 476,740,762 (+403,430)

Sour Candy: 163,318,600 (+311,563)

Stupid Love: 207,022,311 (+273,991)

911: 61,610,435 (+219,577)

[Gypsy Life]

2 hours ago, little legend said:

Stupid Love is literally the worst lead single in human history 

Spill

[Mary Jane Holland]

 

[Laurastreep]

1 hour ago, MissAsia said:

It had bad callouts score.. 

Maybe positions is doing better

Other songs have had bad callouts too yet continued to get spins and power rotation.

Also positions hasn't even debuted at callouts, yet here we are.

Call it what it is...radio payola!

[Andreu]

10 minutes ago, Delusional said:

So they finally gave in 

 

I can't believe it  after all the times she dragged us for asking for one

[Laurastreep]

6 months later and still I can't form a top 3...there's too many good songs ughhhh My top 6 hihihi

Alice, Rain on Me, Babylon, 911, Replay, Sour Candy.