Charts Discussion Thread (911 / Voting Era)

[artgagapop]

9 minutes ago, ViviLittleM said:

Is That Adele? deserved to be a single, at least in France after the Grammy winning I’ll Never Love Again

the way they could have milked both INLA and ITA in most parts of Europe where shallow and ARUTW had smashed and everyone would have eaten it up 

[Moonlight Shadow]

100M views combined for her Super Bowl performance

 

[Moonlight Shadow]

3 minutes ago, Delusional said:

So iconic

I can't even watch it anymore without thinking I miss seeing her performing... That's where she's absolutely the best, she needs to get this honestly

Edited November 14, 2020 by monketsharona

[artgagapop]

Nordics ASIB era vs Chromatica on spotify:

Norway:
#4 Shallow - 38 074 830
#29 Always Remember Us This Way 21 632 181
 
#694 Rain on me 4 621 353
#1806 Stupid Love 874 430 

Sweden:
#6 Shallow 56,337,118
#111 Always Remember Us This Way 25,331,845

#807 Rain on me 6,269,680
#1981 Stupid Love 1,414,675

Iceland:
#2 Shallow 2,567,880
#43 Always Remember Us This Way 1,126,143
#596 I'll Never Love Again - Film Version 193 629

#667 Rain On Me 159,771

Finland:
#36 Shallow 10,583,414
#549 Always Remember Us This Way 3,388,830

#742 Rain on me 2,595,479
#1723 Stupid Love 775,406

Denmark:
#33 Shallow 17,058,764
#636 Always Remember Us This Way 3,893,663

#894 Rain on me 2,665,962

The fact that ROM doesn't even come close to ARUTWs sucess, a song they refused to released as a single vs the song with streaming giant Ariana that was supposed to carry the whole Chromatica era, the nordics really turned on her 

[little legend]

 

omg @entela can you stop using that photo?

i am eating while reading charts discussion and ew

stop it

[ItsGenuineGuy09]

1 hour ago, Fame Romance said:

Apart from Madonna, which women managed to get hits like Shallow or ROM at this point in their careers? 

Britney had a few hits with Femme Fatale at the same point her careers before her commercial career ended, Whitney had her last #1 hit 11 years into her career, Mariah achieved a big comeback 15 years into her career but then dipped, Cher had a last hit with Believe and then nothing, Céline Dion's English career only lasted during the 90's (she would only sing in French in the 80's and charted only in Québec)

Jennifer Lopez, Beyoncé with lemonade... The point is it HAS happened so I don't know why it's being used to excuse the era dying or being handled awfully... 'well she can't have another song on TTH she's not Dua or Harry' well she won't be if they don't make use of what's there effectively Sure the peaks and debuts were nice, but it's like they think she's like Kylie or Madonna somethn and Chromatica went #1 - #50 - OUT 

Surely if you are at this stage of career as keeps being mentioned, you should look at katy and others and think that you should work harder with this genre... I wouldn't even be saying this if the era didn't end after VMAs.. Its not even Gaga. No artists are promoting... Its everything else that could be done to sustain this. Gaga is not an old pensioner.. Fans need to start smelling the coffee! 

[Doncho]

51 minutes ago, Delusional said:

The way I’ve never even listened to Is That Alright 

Am I missing out sistrens?

WTF go listen to it right now. One of Gaga s best ballads alongside the holy trinity of ASIB

[BenG]

1 hour ago, entela said:

There's a reason she called them THE TOILET OF INTERNET and stopped interacting with them for good  

The irony is STRONG with this one

[Ms Arid Lost]

Gaga's monthly listeners (Halloween update): 43.01M

Gaga's current monthly listeners: 42.062M (-950k monthly listeners in a matter of 2 weeks )

At this point she'll be lucky to be at +40M by the end of the year if she keeps serving us nothing. God I love this era 

[Ms Arid Lost]

7 minutes ago, Delusional said:

I find it kind of crazy how 

Taylor Swift, has released 2 more albums than Gaga, has released more videos and singles, and released an album more recently than Gaga yet Gaga is above in monthly listeners 

would Taylor’s absence from streaming affect her current monthly listeners?

I think the difference between Gaga and Taylor is that Taylor has a fixed fanbase, who are the ones who mainly stream her discography whereas Gaga is more appealing to casual listeners, those who stream one song or two of her catalogue and don't appear again in a specific amount of time. But this is just my theory 

[Moonlight Shadow]

18 hours ago, MANiCURE1295 said:

Of course it’s fake, did we really think Gaga was about to collab with Justin 

Not trying to make it happen, but we really should take this carefully : Burns just followed Justin Bieber on Instagram

[Andreu]

Just now, monketsharona said:

Not trying to make it happen, but we really should take this carefully : Burns just followed Justin Bieber on Instagram

well bloodpop worked with JB a lot of times, so maybe they met through him

[Replay]

On 11/8/2020 at 9:46 PM, ViviLittleM said:

The price i-

I think they reduced it now, wasn't it 100 euros when i posted it? It's 60 now

[Andreu]

2 minutes ago, Applause said:

I think they reduced it now, wasn't it 100 euros when i posted it? It's 60 now

do you know exactly what it is? I am confused about it 

[Moonlight Shadow]

Just now, Andreu said:

well bloodpop worked with JB a lot of times, so maybe they met through him

Well the same day Justin Bieber followed Lady Gaga on Instagram ? 

 

Not saying it's happening but we actually got who was involved on Chromatica thanks to the Instagram feeds / followings all through 2018 / 2019 (Burns, Axwell, Skrillex, Madeon... And everyone was saying 'ugh no Ariana on Chromatica' when the rumours happened months before it was confirmed..)

I'd say we should just not forgetting those rumours.

[Replay]

1 minute ago, Andreu said:

do you know exactly what it is? I am confused about it 

Kinda like a frame, it's catered to ppl who buy vinyls just for the sake of lookin at it me thinks. You can hang it on the wall and then somwhow access album and content via app

[Replay]

1 hour ago, artgagapop said:

Nordics ASIB era vs Chromatica on spotify:

Norway:
#4 Shallow - 38 074 830
#29 Always Remember Us This Way 21 632 181
 
#694 Rain on me 4 621 353
#1806 Stupid Love 874 430 

Sweden:
#6 Shallow 56,337,118
#111 Always Remember Us This Way 25,331,845

#807 Rain on me 6,269,680
#1981 Stupid Love 1,414,675

Iceland:
#2 Shallow 2,567,880
#43 Always Remember Us This Way 1,126,143
#596 I'll Never Love Again - Film Version 193 629

#667 Rain On Me 159,771

Finland:
#36 Shallow 10,583,414
#549 Always Remember Us This Way 3,388,830

#742 Rain on me 2,595,479
#1723 Stupid Love 775,406

Denmark:
#33 Shallow 17,058,764
#636 Always Remember Us This Way 3,893,663

#894 Rain on me 2,665,962

The fact that ROM doesn't even come close to ARUTWs sucess, a song they refused to released as a single vs the song with streaming giant Ariana that was supposed to carry the whole Chromatica era, the nordics really turned on her 

it was single basically everywhere but in US

[artgagapop]

I actually wouldn't mind a Gaga x Bieber collab if it's a dance song. Purpose was Justins best and Bloodpop was a major part in that so i think the 3 of them could make something great. Also both Gaga and Justin has said nice things about eachother so i don't think a collab would be as unlikely as some of you might think. 

[ItsGenuineGuy09]

I'm here for the Bieber collab... The #s will do well 

Also, apparently Ari's label thought she'd do less:

[entela]

1 hour ago, ItsGenuineGuy09 said:

Beyoncé with lemonade...

Beyonce hasn't got a hit song for a decade now...