The Journey Continues - Chromatica Ball on MAX- Charts Discussion Thread

[DonnieDarko]

On 4/26/2024 at 11:07 PM, SweetOreosOfHeaven said:

Why won't the critics take her seriously?

Because imo she’s not a rock artist. When she tried to experiment with her sound on Joanne, well, this wasn’t well received at all. We all know they’re kinda harsh on her and they love to put her in a box so I just think they won’t treat a Lady Gaga rock album serious. 
 

Having said that, a dance pop album with rock influences, just like BTW, would be very welcome and imo it’s the way to go. But that’s just me. 

[OliverDespechao Pronounshe/him]

On 4/27/2024 at 2:15 PM, emig_09 said:

Mrs Carpenter at #2 

 

Turning VPN on 

 

[ViviLittleM]

Rain On Me promo

https://vm.tiktok.com/ZGe9KhN7B/

[Moonlight Shadow]

On 4/27/2024 at 9:27 PM, DonnieDarko said:

Because imo she’s not a rock artist. When she tried to experiment with her sound on Joanne, well, this wasn’t well received at all. We all know they’re kinda harsh on her and they love to put her in a box so I just think they won’t treat a Lady Gaga rock album serious. 
 

Having said that, a dance pop album with rock influences, just like BTW, would be very welcome and imo it’s the way to go. But that’s just me. 

I would just love her to go with more experimental dance record with some  industrial techno, funk, rock influences.

Basically almost all of her pop stuff on her 6 albums are dance with different influences. She's a deeply dance artist rooted and she will always be imo. 

[little legend]

Some Katy Kats on ATRL once said that Gagas Superbowl performance looks like an average American Idol performane from a participant with average voice and average performance ability

The audacity to stan Katy Perry and saying this

[Emi Pronounshe/him]

[Ayobabylon PronounsHe/him]

On 4/27/2024 at 8:54 PM, boobatella said:

see that’s why i can’t take Taylor’s huge debuts seriously or feel impressed by the records she breaks, everybody knows how inflated her numbers are by her obsessed fans and streaming farms

Adele had the whole GP in her grip with 25 because of her talent, and her impressive number are organic. People know and love the songs, with Taylor i bet most of the GP can’t even name a single song off her last records

But her numbers are still huge 

2.6 m bc of fans buying multiple copies actually shows her chokehold over her fanbase no one is that loyal 

[Ayobabylon PronounsHe/him]

On 4/27/2024 at 10:53 PM, lookwhatyoumademedo said:

Legendney deserved to have Tay's success in her 30s. It's too bad that her 30s were wasted with two flop eras. Now, she's basically retired. I mostly blame her disgusting family. This shows once again that your family almost always defines your future even if you become very successful.  

 

She was an industry plant who was just a toy for labels to earn money she was forced to release albums and forced to do tours during her peak bc they wanted to use to the time she no longer is benificial to them ans thats what happened

Her albums were made by group of songwriters the biggest one and producers the best in the game 

She was just a voice... She could and can not decide When to peak when she is not behind the creative process

Rihanna was exactlyyy the same till 2012 when she realized that she has to take a different route if she doesn't want to end like every other industry plant and ANTI was that record where she did the impossible and 8 years later she is still eating good on that hype

[Ayobabylon PronounsHe/him]

Gaga n Taylor are the ones who have full creative control over their albums so its unpredictable when they out of the blue release their best body of work 

Beyoncé makes music which is so intricate n radical which we def know what industry's best songwriters n producers are gonna be sitting w her creativity n lead in that studio so it will be excellent

Katy ariana etc are songwriters as well but yk their scope is very limited n they are just going to release cute mainstream pop albums 

[lookwhatyoumademedo]

On 4/28/2024 at 7:19 AM, Ayobabylon said:

Her albums were made by group of songwriters the biggest one and producers the best in the game 

She was just a voice... She could and can not decide When to peak when she is not behind the creative process

Rihanna was exactlyyy the same till 2012 when she realized that she has to take a different route if she doesn't want to end like every other industry plant and ANTI was that record where she did the impossible and 8 years later she is still eating good on that hype

So, no different from Beyonce and Rihanna then.    

Debuting with 16,000 units, failing to win any Grammys, and retiring?

[Ayobabylon PronounsHe/him]

On 4/28/2024 at 11:28 AM, lookwhatyoumademedo said:

So, no different from Beyonce and Rihanna then.    

Debuting with 16,000 units, failing to win any Grammys, and retiring?

But where is the acclaim n longevity though? Rihanna has not seen a 300k debut in her life and britney has not seen an universally acclaimed record 

Beyoncé is a complete artist and there is a reason only her and only herself can be critically acclaimed, radical, impactful and successful at at same time esp in 40-50 age gap 

[lookwhatyoumademedo]

On 4/28/2024 at 9:55 AM, Ayobabylon said:

But where is the acclaim n longevity though? Rihanna has not seen a 300k debut in her life and britney has not seen an universally acclaimed record 

Beyoncé is a complete artist and there is a reason only her and only herself can be critically acclaimed, radical, impactful and successful at at same time esp in 40-50 age gap 

"Radical"

[ViviLittleM]

Joker trailer drop was a fun cute week, now back to nothing, that fad

[Moonlight Shadow]

Met Gala is in one week. Will she show up or just keeping on living under a rock ? 

[ItsGenuineGuy09]

On 4/27/2024 at 8:27 PM, DonnieDarko said:

Because imo she’s not a rock artist. When she tried to experiment with her sound on Joanne, well, this wasn’t well received at all. We all know they’re kinda harsh on her and they love to put her in a box so I just think they won’t treat a Lady Gaga rock album serious. 

 She did jazz and that was well received and that had a lower score than joanne on MC and won a grammy. Joanne was the same 60-71 it has a grammy also lol if being 'well received' is by pleasing moaning f@Gs who only want one thing then she should ignore them and just do what is exactly is she wants to do

 

[Moonlight Shadow]

On 4/28/2024 at 11:33 AM, ItsGenuineGuy09 said:

 She did jazz and that was well received and that had a lower score than joanne on MC and won a grammy. Joanne was the same 60-71 it has a grammy also lol if being 'well received' is by pleasing moaning f@Gs who only want one thing then she should ignore them and just do what is exactly is she wants to do

 

No shade but the CTC Grammy was won in a very easy category that Tony Bennett won 1828494 times

I'm not disminishing the power of CTC but it was a win on lock

Edited April 28 by Moonlight Shadow

[DonnieDarko]

On 4/28/2024 at 11:33 AM, ItsGenuineGuy09 said:

 She did jazz and that was well received and that had a lower score than joanne on MC and won a grammy. Joanne was the same 60-71 it has a grammy also lol if being 'well received' is by pleasing moaning f@Gs who only want one thing then she should ignore them and just do what is exactly is she wants to do

 

Jazz is not a mainstream Lady Gaga release. You know that. It can’t be and shouldn’t be compared to a regular LG studio album, especially when done with the legend of the genre. Joanne was not well received, no matter how much some fans will try to twist it. Her next album, that was, surprise surprise, a comeback to her roots, was very well received and praised by everyone and their mothers (minus a couple of angry fans). The problem with your approach is that you really don’t have to belittle other fans just because they want her to stay true to her roots and do what made her this huge star that she is now. Also, she’s been making dance pop records for years now with the expection of Joanne, so to me it’s exactly what she wants to do and this fanfic that she wants to release hag music and she’s not doing it because she’s listening to her gay fanbase is as flawed as ALL of your other flawed theories. Sorry, mate.

Edited April 28 by DonnieDarko

[danwasd Pronounsthey/them]

C2C and LFS's GRAMMYs were bc of Tony and Jolene's GRAMMY was bc of ASIB 

[danwasd Pronounsthey/them]

#thankyoutony

#thankyouasib

[DonnieDarko]