Charts Discussion Thread - Chromatica Stompage

[Dean Judaster]

On 6/20/2022 at 6:35 PM, Thrasher said:

Rihanna surpassed us with this update?

In that case, I hate it here 

ANTi. Hence the discussion last night about Gaga needing to release her magnum opus that stays on BB200 for like 400 weeks

[Miaou]

On 6/20/2022 at 11:42 PM, danwasd said:

If you want to talk seriously, 99% of the discussions we have both here but also in the stan world in general are either nonsense, non-applicable or directly subjective, but here we are bestie 

Unnonsense then 

[Thrasher]

On 6/20/2022 at 11:44 PM, Dean SMASHchester said:

ANTi. Hence the discussion last night about Gaga needing to release her magnum opus that stays on BB200 for like 400 weeks

Yeah, that’s why I was asking, I hate it here x2

Now we just need Katy to surpass GaGa as well thanks to TD only 

[Dean Judaster]

On 6/20/2022 at 6:48 PM, Thrasher said:

Yeah, that’s why I was asking, I hate it here x2

Now we just need Katy to surpass GaGa as well thanks to TD only 

Gaga's US stats are truly trash compared to her achievements in other markets

[little legend]

Sour ties The Fame as the debut album with the most weeks inside top 10 in the US. Next week will surpass us

[Miaou]

Yeah this is why Gaga lack of longevity in her career if we remove ASIB and TF/TFM

she chose with BTW/AP and Chromatica to “pleased” a certain community in general (the gays) and not the GP like a lot of her peers 

 

[Gagacharts]

Gaga´s Spotify Update:

 

Top Gun: Maverick - 395.276.333 (+4.040.237)

The Fame - 2.095.404.204 (+1.348.102)

The Fame Monster - 1.698.313.536 (+888.769)

Born This Way - 1.314.589.185 (+870.697)

Chromatica - 2.016.429.899 (+790.156)

Joanne - 1.378.465.554 (+346.190)

ARTPOP - 779.018.242 (+279.173)

 

*huge drop for every album, was there some kind of holiday?

[Dean Judaster]

On 6/20/2022 at 6:52 PM, Miaou said:

Yeah this is why Gaga lack of longevity in her career if we remove ASIB and TF/TFM

she chose with BTW/AP and Chromatica to “pleased” a certain community in general (the gays) and not the GP like a lot of her peers 

 

Also what happens if she keeps releasing 1 proper single per era. It's like triple whammy for her because single sales and streams drive album equivalent, momentum, GP recognition and familiarity of an album.

@Gagacharts Father's day no?

[Gagacharts]

Gaga´s overall Spotify streams:

 

12.06: +7.882.817

13.06: +8.506.039

14.06: +8.740.245

15.06: +8.895.540

16.06: +8.842.736

17.06: +9.230.330

18.06: +8.786.230

19.06: +7.812.891

 

Total - 14.192.586.222

[Imtired1616]

On 6/20/2022 at 5:41 PM, Miaou said:

Again it shows how amazing her team was to choose these two songs as lead singles 

The sad part is, they sat on SL for 2 years because they were sure it was a hit.

I love SL, just not as the lead....

[Emi Pronounshe/him]

On 6/20/2022 at 6:44 PM, Dean SMASHchester said:

ANTi. Hence the discussion last night about Gaga needing to release her magnum opus that stays on BB200 for like 400 weeks

Wow a person as Rih who has her first #1 album in her 7th try is above us...

[OreoÀDeux Pronounshe/him]

On 6/20/2022 at 11:02 PM, emig_09 said:

Wow a person as Rih who has her first #1 album in her 7th try is above us...

which means it's never too late

[OreoÀDeux Pronounshe/him]

Gags was already predicting Haus Labs when writing ARTPOP, her mind

The colour palette you choose, can profit you

 

[loopyjae]

I've always found Gaga’s success extremely... weird? Because while she's legendary already and her achievements are well known, her name never seems to be up there when it comes to the longevity of her peers, even Katy, who is basically not even half as relevant as she used to, do streaming numbers similar to ours which is sad  Also, I've noticed Gaga has never really been a GP darling, she just happens to have a few "viral" cultural moments but when those are over the GP moves on a quickness. It's weird. 

[ryanripley Pronounshe/him]

on the edge of glory like im gaga, gaga

Spoiler

sorry but i love this

 

 

[zoldyck]

They messed up by giving Bradley Cooper a lead credit on ASIB album.

 

She would have been higher than Rihanna and also made it to top 10 of 2010s top artists, if Bradley credit was downgraded to feature. 70% of ASIB soundtrack is Gaga. 

[Miaou]

On 6/21/2022 at 12:02 AM, emig_09 said:

Wow a person as Rih who has her first #1 album in her 7th try is above us...

this is why longevity >>>>> huge peak the first week 

 

[little legend]

On 6/21/2022 at 12:12 AM, loopyjae said:

I've always found Gaga’s success extremely... weird? Because while she's legendary already and her achievements are well known, her name never seems to be up there when it comes to the longevity of her peers, even Katy, who is basically not even half as relevant as she used to, do streaming numbers similar to ours which is sad  Also, I've noticed Gaga has never really been a GP darling, she just happens to have a few "viral" cultural moments but when those are over the GP moves on a quickness. It's weird. 

Well during her peak she didn't have just a few viral culture moments. She was the pop culture. For 3 years straight she was everywhere. Her music was playing everywhere, she was talked all the time on the news, she was talked by the GP ,her music videos were events and etc. 

 

But yeah recently it's been like this. But still during ASIB she was still everywhere. Then with Chromatica,we had covid so she didn't promote and she didn't release something big since then to create a big hype. Unfortunately it's kinda true that from 2013-2022 if you exclude ASIB era, she doesn't have longevity but it's ok ,she can't be massive and on her peak forever. But she deserves a bit better longevity:/

[ryanripley Pronounshe/him]

On 6/20/2022 at 11:24 PM, zoldyck said:

They messed up by giving Bradley Cooper a lead credit on ASIB album.

 

She would have been higher than Rihanna and also made it to top 10 of 2010s top artists, if Bradley credit was downgraded to feature. 70% of ASIB soundtrack is Gaga. 

that wouldn't be fair to do since he's got a few solo songs

and lowkey they're my favs

i would be a jackson maine stan 

[LGMonster95]

On 6/21/2022 at 1:12 AM, loopyjae said:

I've always found Gaga’s success extremely... weird? Because while she's legendary already and her achievements are well known, her name never seems to be up there when it comes to the longevity of her peers, even Katy, who is basically not even half as relevant as she used to, do streaming numbers similar to ours which is sad  Also, I've noticed Gaga has never really been a GP darling, she just happens to have a few "viral" cultural moments but when those are over the GP moves on a quickness. It's weird. 

Streaming just ain't everything too bc if we talk about who's gonna sell a lot more tickets between Gaga and Katy, Gaga is gonna win by far without any questions. Gaga just came to the streaming party later, she just doesn't follow the trends and beside this she releases a lot less singles. Gaga overall has kind of always did her own thing when it comes to music, if it sticks to the GP, it sticks, if not then she moves on. This is just my take on it.